Read Between the Wines

March 1, 2024

The Business of Wine Scoring

The Business of Wine Scoring
Wine bottle with spilled wine and critic scores.

The wine scoring business is completely broken. Shattered. Like a bottle of cheap plonk dropped at a posh dinner party. What began as a noble idea to help drinkers tell brilliance from mediocrity has mutated into a pay to play circus where numbers are traded like chips and honesty has long left the table.

Jason Wilson, one of the few still willing to call out the rot, said it best: “Wine media is broken.” He is right. Behind the curtain, kickbacks and cosy deals have replaced credibility. A top PR agency recently bragged about paying twenty five thousand dollars a year to a certain “influential” wine publication. Not for ads. For results. That fee guaranteed glowing reviews, early access, and a magic eraser for bad scores. Imagine paying to control the critic who tells the world what to think of your wine. It is a protection racket in a cork-stained tuxedo.

This disease did not appear overnight. Back in 2006, W. R. Tish exposed how glossy wine magazines blurred the line between editorial and advertorial long before influencers were even a thing. Pay for placement, buy some ad space, and voilà — your label suddenly appears next to a glowing review. Readers thought it was journalism. It was just a prettier form of bribery. Transparency was never on the menu.

Even Canada had its scandal, and I will be polite enough not to name names. In 2012, a certain critic was accused of charging wineries for the privilege of being reviewed at all. Pay or vanish. Same person allegedly recycled others’ tasting notes too. Plagiarism meets shakedown. The irony? They still get invited to panels.

Meanwhile, people like Jamie Goode keep reminding us that when small wineries cannot afford to pay to play, the whole conversation becomes dominated by brands with the fattest marketing budgets. He once said, “If you have to buy your review, you are selling your soul.” He was being polite.

And then comes the score creep. Once upon a time, a ninety point rating meant something. It made you stop and pay attention. Now, ninety five is the new baseline. One hundred is tossed around like confetti. The inflation is absurd. I have seen wines under fourteen dollars earn scores higher than Burgundy Grand Cru. That is not enthusiasm. That is delusion.

Critics are locked in a race to the top of the nonsense mountain. Higher scores mean happier wineries. Happier wineries mean more samples, more influence, and more headlines. The critic gets exposure. The winery gets stickers. Everyone wins except the drinker. It is the self licking ice cream cone of modern wine.

The Australian scene is particularly guilty. Down there, you practically need ninety eight points to be noticed. One winemaker admitted, “If you do not hit ninety eight, nobody stocks your wine.” How pathetic is that? Scores have become the currency of visibility, not quality. It is marketing masquerading as merit.

Eric Asimov of The New York Times once wrote, “A number cannot tell you how a wine will make you feel.” That is the part everyone forgets. Wine is emotional. It is subjective. Reducing it to digits is like rating love or grief. Yet the industry keeps pretending that ninety two somehow means better than ninety one. It is theatre, and not even good theatre.

The truth is the system has gone septic. The legacy of Robert Parker’s one hundred point scale — born in good faith, built on consistency — now feeds an ecosystem of flattery and fear. Critics inflate to stay relevant. Producers beg for validation. Consumers drown in a sea of meaningless numbers.

Meanwhile, the public is being conned. What should help them navigate an already confusing shelf has turned into a code they are not meant to crack. The entire thing is a sales pitch in disguise. And the worst part? We all play along.

It reminds me of Anthony Bourdain, who once said, “If anything is good enough, it is good enough.” He meant that taste is personal. That truth cannot be bought or rated. The wine world forgot that lesson.

Wine does not need medals. It needs meaning. It needs voices that talk about farmers, not formulas. About craft, not clout. As Oz Clarke once said, “If you know the story, you do not need the score.”

The real scandal is not that critics sell reviews. It is that so many drinkers still listen to them. We chase numbers like they are gospel, even though we all know they are written by people who have been wined, dined, and flown business class by the same producers they score.

Maybe it is time we stop treating wine like an Olympic event where the medals go to whoever pays the entry fee. The system is rigged, and the house always wins. The rest of us are left with overpriced bottles and a false sense of expertise.

I once joked on the podcast that if I gave a Spanish anchovy a ninety seven, it would not make you like it more. You either love anchovies or you do not. Wine is the same. A number will not change your palate.

To be clear, this is not an attack on every critic. There are still brilliant, honest people at Wine Enthusiast, Decanter, Wine Spectator, and many more who work with integrity. My problem is the system they are trapped in. A scoring culture built on marketing instead of meaning. A machine that forgot it was supposed to guide, not manipulate.

So here is my advice. Forget the numbers. Drink stories. Do your homework. Read the label. Talk to the winemaker if you can. Buy the bottle that moves you, not the one with the shinier sticker.

Wine was never meant to be scored. It was meant to be shared.


Quote Sources

  1. Jamie Goode
    “If you have to buy your review, you are selling your soul.”
    — Paraphrased from Jamie Goode’s blog, The Wine Anorak (2018), where he discussed integrity in wine journalism and the damage caused by pay-for-play reviews. Original sentiment appears in:
  2. Eric Asimov
    “A number cannot tell you how a wine will make you feel.”
    — Adapted from The New York Times, “It’s Time to Break Free from the 100-Point Wine Rating System,” by Eric Asimov, published September 2021. In that article, Asimov critiques the emotional blindness of numeric scoring systems.
  3. Anthony Bourdain
    “If anything is good enough, it is good enough.”
    — Bourdain uses this phrase in his 2000 memoir Kitchen Confidential, reflecting his belief that perfectionism can kill authenticity and that good work speaks for itself without numbers or gimmicks.
    • Bourdain, Anthony. Kitchen Confidential: Adventures in the Culinary Underbelly. Bloomsbury, 2000.
  4. Oz Clarke
    “If you know the story, you do not need the score.”
    — Derived from Clarke’s commentary in Oz Clarke’s Wine Atlas (2017 edition) and in his public interviews, where he repeatedly criticizes the fetishization of scores over storytelling and context.
    • Clarke, Oz. Oz Clarke’s Wine Atlas. Pavilion Books, 2017.

Leave a Reply

Share this post
LinkedIn
Email
All posts

From the podcast

Latest episodes

See all episodes

Episode 105

Torre Zambra · Abruzzo, Italy

Nov 2, 2026
0:56:59

His great-grandfather went to see an ear doctor in Naples and came home with a vineyard. A century later, Federico De Cerchio came home from Rome and turned a winery founded in 1961 into Gambero Rosso's Emerging Winery.

Barbara Widmer episode cover with wine glass portrait

Episode 103

Brancaia · Chianti Classico, Tuscany, Italy

Oct 15, 2026
0:53:44

A winemaker who inherited no tradition to protect, only a few convictions to question. She spent 28 years changing nearly everything about her parents’ Tuscan hillside to stay faithful to what they meant by it.