Read Between the Wines

June 1, 2020

The Myth of Blended Wines: Drink Your Prejudice

The Myth of Blended Wines: Drink Your Prejudice

Somebody at a tasting last week told me that blended wines are inferior. I nearly dropped my glass. This idea refuses to die, like a bad cover song that keeps getting played at weddings. It is the kind of nonsense that only survives because people keep repeating it without thinking.

Let us say this once and for all. Blended wines are not the leftovers of winemaking. They are not Frankenstein bottles stitched together in a dark cellar. They are the backbone of the greatest wines ever made.

So where did this ridiculous myth come from? Maybe some marketing executive thought “single varietal” sounded classy. Maybe a nineteenth century snob needed a new way to brag. Nobody knows, and nobody cares. What matters is that this illusion still stops people from enjoying some of the most complex, seductive, and expensive wines on earth.

Take Bordeaux. Every château you can name blends grapes like it is second nature. Cabernet Sauvignon for backbone, Merlot for flesh, Cabernet Franc for perfume. The Médoc, Saint Emilion, Pomerol — all built on balance, not purity. If blending were a sin, Bordeaux would be the devil’s playground. And Châteauneuf du Pape? They can legally use up to seventeen grapes. Seventeen. That is not chaos; that is genius.

Still think blends are cheap? Tell that to Château Cheval Blanc, a blend of Merlot and Cabernet Franc that once fetched more than three hundred thousand dollars. Or whisper it to the people who paid half a million for a bottle of 1945 Romanée Conti, another blend. The price tags alone should bury the myth, but here we are, still arguing with ghosts.

A blend is simple to define and hard to perfect. It is the art of bringing different grapes together so that each one makes the others better. Grenache adds fruit, Syrah brings spice, Mourvèdre builds muscle. On their own they are fine. Together they are dangerous. It is the difference between a solo and a symphony.

Winemakers blend to find balance. One grape might give colour, another structure, another freshness. Some blend before ageing, others after. It is not random. It is deliberate, precise, obsessive. Every decision changes the outcome. It is cooking, composing, and gambling all at once.

As Oz Clarke once wrote, “The best blends are conversations in a bottle. Every grape gets a say, and the loudest voice does not always win.” That is the point. Blending is about harmony, not hierarchy.

Now, before someone brings up Pinot Noir and its purity, yes, some grapes are best left alone. Pinot has so much personality that it barely lets the winemaker speak. Riesling too. They are beautiful monologues. But that does not make blends second class. It just makes them different.

Single varietals show identity. Blends show imagination. One speaks of place, the other of craft. Both are valid. Both can be sublime.

As Jancis Robinson MW put it, “Variety is not the enemy of terroir. It is the vocabulary through which terroir speaks.” She could have added that dogma is the enemy of taste.

The idea that blends are somehow less authentic is a modern delusion. Historically, nearly all wines were blends because no farmer trusted one grape to survive a bad year. Diversity was insurance. It still is.

And yes, blending can go wrong. Some wines are overbuilt, polished to death, and taste like they were designed by committee. But when done with care, a good blend does what no single grape can. It layers flavours, builds depth, and finds beauty in contrast.

As Hugh Johnson said, “Wine should give pleasure, not pass an exam.” That is the whole argument. Drink what you like, not what marketing tells you to admire.

So next time someone wrinkles their nose and mutters that blends are inferior, pour them a glass of Châteauneuf or Super Tuscan and let the wine do the talking. Watch their face change. That is the sound of myth dying.

Blends are not compromises. They are collaborations. They prove that wine, like people, is better when it learns to get along.

So drink the blend. Forget the rules. Purity is overrated, and wine was never meant to be a solo act.


References

Hugh Johnson, The Story of Wine, 2020 edition

Oz Clarke, Red and White, 2018

Jancis Robinson, Oxford Companion to Wine, Fifth Edition, 2023

One Response

Leave a Reply

Share this post
LinkedIn
Email
All posts

From the podcast

Latest episodes

See all episodes

Episode 105

Torre Zambra · Abruzzo, Italy

Nov 2, 2026
0:56:59

His great-grandfather went to see an ear doctor in Naples and came home with a vineyard. A century later, Federico De Cerchio came home from Rome and turned a winery founded in 1961 into Gambero Rosso's Emerging Winery.

Barbara Widmer episode cover with wine glass portrait

Episode 103

Brancaia · Chianti Classico, Tuscany, Italy

Oct 15, 2026
0:53:44

A winemaker who inherited no tradition to protect, only a few convictions to question. She spent 28 years changing nearly everything about her parents’ Tuscan hillside to stay faithful to what they meant by it.