Read Between the Wines

September 4, 2025

WINERY MARKETING in 2026: Storytelling is the New Currency

WINERY MARKETING in 2026: Storytelling is the New Currency
Man recording in vineyard with microphone.

The wine world is changing fast. The competition is growing, but so is the opportunity. The wineries that will win are not the ones shouting the most. They are the ones speaking the clearest.

How do I know? Because at Between the Wines Media Productions, we live it every day. Our podcast, Read Between the Wines, reaches more than 40,000 listeners in 55 countries and is licensed on six major international airlines. Our guests are the who’s who of the wine world — from Burgundy to Tuscany, from the Barossa to South Africa and beyond. We talk to winemakers, vintners, and wine lovers daily about the industry and its challenges. That is how we know. We know that storytelling builds trust. Trust builds loyalty. Loyalty builds growth. We know that your wines already speak of your land. Let your voice speak for your brand.

How to Unmute Your Winery

Let’s begin with a question to winemakers & vintners: what are you sharing more often: your story or your specs and awards? For decades the wine world has been obsessed with numbers. Points, ratings, gold medals and various obscur awards. But a score has never made anyone fall in love.

What people truly remember is a voice, a face, a story that moves them, something they can attach to emotionally. According to a 2024 review of wine marketing research by Martínez-Navarro, the shift in consumer behaviour is clear: “authentic narrative appeal is replacing traditional extrinsic cues in many segments”. 

Here’s the hard truth: the next generation of wine drinkers do not care about 95 points in a glossy magazine. They care about people. They care about places. They care about purpose. They want to know who is behind the label, what ideas & purpose drives the winemaker, and why the wine exists. They are not impressed by a critic’s approval. They are inspired by authenticity.

Many wineries still hide behind silence, afraid to talk about themselves. But silence does not sell. Silence is not connection. When you unmute your winery, you transform from a product to a presence. People do not want more wine. They want meaning. Remember: culture in a bottle.

Storytelling as the New Currency

Storytelling is not a marketing trick. It is the most human form of communication we have. People remember stories twenty times more than facts. Stories build emotion. Emotion builds trust. Trust builds loyalty. And loyalty, in a crowded market, is everything.

Every vineyard already holds a library of stories. The grandfather who planted the first vines with a shovel and hope. The frost that nearly destroyed the crop, yet produced a remarkable vintage. The winemaker who left a city career after tasting a bottle that changed everything.

These are not just anecdotes. They are gold, and if you’ve ever been a guest on our podcast, you already know we call them “golden nuggets”.

Academic research backs this up. For example, a working paper published by the American Association of Wine Economists (AAWE) on Georgian wine found that “storytelling can be considered an augmented value proposition” for wine brands. Another recent study of 647 wine-tourists in Portugal showed that storytelling has a direct impact on wine-excitation and on a traveller’s cultural experience. 

Stories make your wines come alive before the cork is pulled. They travel further than any advertisement. They connect hearts, not just palates.

Here’s something I’ve talked about often on the podcast: anyone who has ever visited a winery knows that wine tastes different where it’s made. You stand among the vines, you meet the winemaker, the sun is soft, the air smells like earth and promise, and the wine sings. Then you bring that same bottle home, open it on a Tuesday night with a questionable Kung Pao Chicken delivered by Skip the Dishes, and suddenly it feels… ordinary. That moment of enchantment is gone.

That is what I call the Tasting Room Spell. It is not deceitful. It is human. Context changes perception. The wine was good, but the story, the setting, and the people made it unforgettable.

A good story does for your wine what that visit did for your guest: it sets the stage, creates the mood, and invites emotion before the first sip. It lets the wine live in someone’s imagination long before they pour it into a glass.

That is the power of storytelling. It recreates the feeling of being there, the warmth of your hospitality, the smell of the cellar, the laugh of the person pouring the wine. When you tell that story well, people will not just remember the taste. They will remember the moment.

Because long before the cork is pulled, the story has already opened the bottle.

What the Research Says

A landmark study by “The Influence of Product Knowledge on the Relative Importance of Extrinsic Product Attributes of Wine” published in 2018 by Jeandri Robertson, Caitlin Ferreira & Elsamari Botha showed how consumers’ buying behaviour changes with what they know and what they think they know. The study segments wine-buyers into four groups: Neophytes (low objective & subjective knowledge), focus on price; Snobs (low objective, high subjective), chase brand and prestige; Modest Experts (high objective, low subjective) care about origin and authenticity and finally Experts (high knowledge both ways), we called them Real Wine Enthusiats rely on terroir, process, and story.

One key takeaway: one message does not fit all. You must speak different languages within the same story. For beginners you need warmth, simplicity, and emotion; for the experts you need depth, honesty, and a sense of exploration. Storytelling bridges both. It allows you to meet people where they are, and bring them closer to who you are.

The End of Wine Scoring (as the holy grail of wine marketing)

Let’s talk about something delicate. Wine scoring.

For decades, scores were indeed the holy grail. They were shorthand for quality, credibility, and pride. A good review could move cases overnight. A bad one could sting for a season. Many wineries still depend on them. And that is fine. Wine scoring is not dead – it is simply no longer enough – it’s just data and all of us are drowing in data… 

Of course, there is still an audience for it. Collectors, certain trade buyers, and a slice of traditional wine lovers continue to trust critics and point systems. Those people read the guides, follow the competitions, and appreciate expert validation. A score can still – to a certain limit – open doors, help with export, and provide some social proof.

But here’s the hard truth: that audience is shrinking. Younger drinkers, the people who will soon make up most of your market, do not buy wine that way. They are unimpressed by numbers. They are moved by narratives. When they choose a bottle, they are not thinking “This one got 94 points.” They are thinking “This wine reminds me of that trip to Tuscany,” or “I love the story of this winemaker who went organic.”

A score may get attention once, but a story builds a relationship. That is why scores should live in your marketing, but never lead it. Think of them as seasoning, not the meal.

And if you ever want proof, try explaining wine-scoring to a casual drinker. Watch their eyes glaze over as you attempt to justify one critic’s 93 points might be another platform’s 88. And then comes the awkward question: does that local newspaper critic accept payment in exchange for “high scores”? The truth is, most people do not know. What they want to know is actual stories: who made the wine, where it comes from, how it’s made and why it matters.

If your website or label begins and ends with a number or medals and awards, you have already lost half your potential audience. But if you use that same space to tell your story, the people, the land, the challenges, you invite the reader into your world.

A wine score can support the story. It can confirm what the story already suggests. For example: “Our 2021 Syrah earned 93 points from Wine Enthusiast, but what makes us proudest is the story behind it. It was the vintage when frost wiped out half the valley, and our team, helped by dozens of residents of the village, spent nights burning hay to protect the vines. The result isn’t just a number. It’s proof of resilience.”

In that context, the score does not create emotion. The story does. The score simply provides another angle. There is nothing wrong with celebrating recognition from respected critics. In fact, you should. Post it. Frame it. Toast it. But never confuse the score for the story.

Because a score stops the conversation. A story keeps it going. Scores measure wine once. Stories make people return. Numbers are proof of achievement, but stories are proof of soul.

The future belongs to wineries that understand this balance. Use the points if you have them, but lead with your voice, your place, your truth. A number may impress someone’s intellect. A story will capture their heart.

Podcasting: The Modern Vineyard of Stories

Let me share something from my own journey. When I launched Read Between the Wines, I wanted to create a space where wineries could talk, not sell. Where their story could be heard with honesty, warmth and depth.

Today that podcast is listened to in more than 55 countries and streamed on major airlines. Every week, tens of thousands of wine lovers tune in to hear winemakers speak from the heart. They listen while cooking, travelling or relaxing with a glass in hand. This is not an ad. It is authentics connection. We receive dozens of emails each week from our audience about the stories we share, not about the scores attributed by other publications. A podcast is not a social post that disappears tomorrow. It is an evergreen archive. Once your story is told, it lives online for years and continues to be discovered. And that is where your opportunity lies.

You do not need to build an audience. We already have one. You just need to step up and share your story.

Being featured on a podcast like Read Between the Wines is not just an interview. It is a brand experience. It puts your story in the ears of people who care. It gives your winery credibility, reach and a human voice. It unmutes your winery.

Person holding microphone in vineyard

Wine is About People and Place

Behind every great wine there is someone who refused to give up. Wine is not just fermented grapes. It is soil, sun, struggle and soul.

When you tell that story, you give meaning to every sip. Think about the vineyards you know. The ones that linger in memory are not the ones with the biggest awards. They are the ones that made you feel something.

Wine is never about perfection. It is about people and place. About laughter in the cellar, boots in the mud, patience in the rain.

That is what storytelling brings to life. It turns geography into emotion. It makes vineyard breathe through words.

The Next Chapters of Wine Marketing

The wine world is changing fast. The competition is louder, but so is the opportunity. The wineries that will win are not the ones shouting the most. They are the ones speaking the clearest.

Storytelling builds trust. Trust builds loyalty. Loyalty builds growth. Your wines already speak of your land. Let your voice speak for your brand.

Read Between the Wines was built for that. It is where stories travel. Where your voice can fly on airlines, stream in homes, and echo across continents. Because in 2026, being heard is no longer optional, it is essential.

And this is only the beginning. In my next piece, we will explore how to turn your story into lasting connection and growth.

We will look at social media — your daily storyboard, where your narrative continues long after the bottle is empty. We will explore the power of wine clubs, the most direct way to build loyalty, community, and predictable revenue. And finally, we will examine one of the most overlooked pillars of modern marketing: web strategy.

For that, I will be joined by Chris Upright, Co-Founder of Fresh Start Digital — the team we trust completely with our own web strategy. This partnership goes beyond design. Together, we help wineries define their full brand identity, from storytelling to digital presence. Chris brings more than two decades of experience leading complex digital projects and an exceptional understanding of how to be seen, heard, and found online. His team combines creativity with technical precision, ensuring that every website they craft performs as beautifully as it looks.

In today’s market, a website is not decoration. It is discovery. And with Chris Upright and Fresh Start Digital, we are building the bridge that lets wineries turn their story into presence and their presence into growth. Because even the best wines cannot sell themselves in silence.

Wine has always been about people and places. Now it is also about presence. The microphone is ready. The audience is waiting. It is time to unmute your winery.

Leave a Reply

Share this post
LinkedIn
Email
All posts

From the podcast

Latest episodes

See all episodes

Episode 105

Torre Zambra · Abruzzo, Italy

November 3, 2026 0:56:59

His great-grandfather went to see an ear doctor in Naples and came home with a vineyard. A century later, Federico De Cerchio came home from Rome and turned a winery founded in 1961 into Gambero Rosso's Emerging Winery.

Episode 104

Spy Valley Wines · Marlborough, New Zealand

November 3, 2026 0:51:27

A winery named after the real spy base next door, built on land everyone else thought was too barren to plant. Decades later, it is one of New Zealand’s most decorated producers, and still in on its own joke.

Barbara Widmer episode cover with wine glass portrait

Episode 103

Brancaia · Chianti Classico, Tuscany, Italy

November 3, 2026 0:53:44

A winemaker who inherited no tradition to protect, only a few convictions to question. She spent 28 years changing nearly everything about her parents’ Tuscan hillside to stay faithful to what they meant by it.