Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines – INTRO:
About a year ago, I walked into a wine tasting in Toronto and tasted around thirty wines that night. One stopped me cold. One name, one label, one wine struck me above all others — for the quality, the complexity, and the sheer singularity of what was in the glass. That wine was Xavier. A few weeks later, the same Canadian agency that brought Xavier Vignon’s wines to Ontario — Noble Estates — organized a special tasting event with none other than Xavier Vignon himself. He had a packed schedule in Toronto. I convinced him to sit down with me anyway. This is Read Between the Wines, Episode 47. Xavier Vignon is the winemaker behind the Xavier label, and the consultant responsible for some of the finest estates in Châteauneuf-du-Pape and the surrounding Southern Rhône for over fifteen years. Originally from Picardy, in northern France — where he found his calling — he left to forge his expertise in Champagne and Bordeaux, then traveled further still, including time in Australia learning everything the vine had to teach him. In 1996, during what he called his Tour de France — not on a bike, but with a glass — he fell in love with the Dentelles de Montmirail, a small chain of mountains in Provence. A coup de coeur, he said. He never really left. This is where he established himself and became an extraordinary figure of the region — a pioneer who dared to experiment, challenge preconceived ideas, and draw inspiration from his travels in ways few winemakers of his generation were willing to. I have met hundreds of winemakers in my life. I have interviewed dozens of them. Without a doubt, Xavier Vignon is the most impressive, the most unique winemaker I have ever encountered. And to start our conversation, I asked him the simplest possible question: Why? Why the Rhône?
Xavier Vignon:
Why? Good question. I fell in love. I fell in love with… I was back from Australia. I started in ‘88 to make my wine experience. And the challenge was to make the Tour de France, not by bike, but with my glass and I discovered also the Southern hemisphere. So between ‘88 and ‘96 I was making… [inaudible] – It was a great job and funny discovered around the world. And I was close to sign a contract to stay in Australia for making sparkling, rosé, right, lovely country too, but I was missing one region in France to finalize this Tour de France was the Southern Rhône Valley. So I came back in August ‘96 and it was really like a shock. I fell in love with the Dentelles de Montmirail with this area. The one was not very well known 27 years ago, but my feeling was, this is the place to be. There is a big future here and you can play with all the tools you have used before. This is a lovely place with 27 different varieties, many appellations exposed in a different altitude. And it was really like we say in French “un coup de coeur”.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
So we know that Châteauneuf-du-Pape, the area per se, was established already. But what did you find close to that mountain that grabbed your heart like the Dentelles de Montmirail. So what was exactly about the terroir – what did you see that other people didn’t see?
Xavier Vignon:
What I have seen there, is the opportunity to move because already – now it’s not a drug and people start to speak about that, but you know, 25 years ago and more, global warming was like a drug, but I was coming from Australia and I have seen that the climate has changed so fast. And I was believing with this opportunity to go up all the terroir, everywhere they are moving to the north and to the altitude, they are moving up and up to the north and up to the mountain and the Dentelles, they gave me the opportunity to see a future for the next decade. You have already some vineyards planted at more than 600 metres altitude, you know, and in the same time, the alcohol became to be a problem; the ripeness, the dryness and, but I was right because now it’s more than a drug and it’s just the reality and I still believe in the future of the Dentelles… It’s, of course, Châteauneuf-du-Pape was very well known, very famous, and I used to work with only famous well-known estates, everything, but – in their own, it was really fan about what the people didn’t know already. You know, when we spoke about Ventoux 25 years ago, Luberon, even Côtes-du-Rhône was considered like ok, average quality like Languedoc-Roussillon, but for me to be honest, my feeling was wow, there is so many different terroir so many, it’s like a garden, a paradise garden to play with. And my feeling was here with all this type of terroir, I was almost sure that it’s a good place to give pleasure to everybody. It’s not easy when – I remember I was in Bordeaux so I used to work in Burgundy before. So, can you test this Pinot Noir? Oh, no, no, I don’t like, you know, the French sometimes are too French and, they, they don’t want to, they are not so open to another area. It’s difficult to give a good bottle for Burgundy guy and… but in the Rhône – with everything, all that, oh I couldn’t make a party – blend and make everybody happy. People from Burgundy, people from Bordeaux. And as for me making a wine is really making something serious but funny. In the same time, my feeling was that the Rhône is like a gift. You can take pleasure and give pleasure to many, many people.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Yesterday, we had a great dinner together – Thank you very much. We’re gonna tell the story about the Guide Hachette in a minute because I want to tell that story. It’s, it’s a, it’s a funny story. But before the Guide Hachette, I want you to tell us about, to share with us, your first bottle that you did. How did it start? What was – who was your audience or customers? Because I think it was mostly friends. How did it work? How, what was the critique?
Xavier Vignon:
Yeah. It was only friends and to be honest, I told you when I arrived in Rhône and the Rhône was not considered like a big region for making wine. And I used to work with very big names. You know, it can be, Don Perignon, it can be in Bordeaux and in burgundy only big names. And I was always on the move like a ping pong with – North hemisphere, South hemisphere – making harvest. And many people offered to me to stay and I always said no. But the only thing, the only time I said yes was in the Rhône. And when I told that to my friends: “Xavier, what are you doing? You should be in Champagne […] Why are you stopping in the Rhône?” And it was like a drug, but I was a bit disturbed by that. OK. No, I believed in the quality to the wine. So the first wine I have made, we are not at all for selling – It was just to show to my friends. I bought a tank – a tank of five hectolitres. The unit, the biggest blend I have done at the beginning, was one pallet, 50 cases of 12 not – for selling – just to give away to friends. Let’s go, try this Ventoux, this Beaumes-de-Venise, this Vacqueyras, the Gigondas… and some bottles arrived […] it was for free. It was just to give a gift and then, and then sunny…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
You were not the best businessman at that point…
Xavier Vignon:
No, no, no, I did not do in business school, everything was just winemaking, winemaking…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Ok. So now I wanna jump into that story – The Guide Hachette puts you in their, in their books. So for those who are not familiar with the Guide Hachette is a wine guide in France. It’s almost like a travel book, a travel guide where you have the address and where to go and a little bit of explanation. It’s a little bit like the Guide Routard, but for mostly for food and wine – am I correct ?
Xavier Vignon:
Yes, and especially 25 years ago was really the, maybe the only book considered like serious, with all the writes and then every year or every September or new edition with the discovering of the year, everything. And I did not present any samples but what – some friends, some two producers, they made the draw and then, they sent the samples from my selection without telling me. So they send the samples in April, May, I think it was in March, sorry, and, and without telling me… So the samples arrived to the Guide Hachette and they put themselves because there was no label on my bottles. It was not for commercial way, it was just for samples, but they put writing in Xavier Ventoux, Xavier Côte-du-Rhône, Xavier Beaume-de-Venise, Xavier Châteauneuf-du-Pape – and the that was a problem because when the Guide was published early September, I was really busy with the consulting. And then one day, one Monday morning, I received so many calls and that’s happened: they put my personal home address, they put the samples with my mobile phone number, personal home address. They checked that I was doing accommodation – open seven days a week and six of these wines, they were elected at least three stars and one was “coup de coeur” means with the photo and everybody wants everyone to see it. So, I was living in a small village, medieval village and many cars arrived and they were sick because: “Oh where is Xavier ? […] And it became a nightmare. Believe me, there was after three days, there were many complaints, and then I finished with two lawyers and the mayor and then.. we have to find a solution and the only solution we found, OK, somebody from the City Hall was open a garage and then just to be able to give one bottle, pair, one bottle to the people coming to my address. And it’s funny that that’s why I I did not I show I have to to sell some wines from the beginning.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
So did you find out exactly like who made the decision without consulting with you about the name of the wine and your address and giving your personal address and phone number. So they did this, like, just like…
Xavier Vignon:
For them, it was just a joke for me. Oh, let’s go to do that. And we’ll see. It’s one producer from Châteauneuf-du-Pape. He’s still a good friend and one from Beaume-de-Venise. And they had dinner and then said, let’s go to them because sometimes it was the third year I started to make my selection and sometimes I take a bit of their wine still like I’m doing now. And they say, oh, let’s go. It was really the joke at the beginning and the joke became a nightmare because of the law because when you are in a book, then many writers and then that was, that was a strange, strange time. And then because of that, I had to officially becoming a négociant. And, yeah, it was in 2000, so…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
This is quite something: a joke between two friends at dinner — and it changed the entire trajectory of your career. Sometimes the best business plans are the ones you never made. Now — Châteauneuf-du-Pape. An appellation built on assemblage, with seventeen authorized varieties — thirteen reds, four whites. That freedom to blend is at the heart of everything you do. But is there a hierarchy? A varietal that sits above the others?
Xavier Vignon:
Yes, 17; 13 reds and 4 white wines.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Thirteen reds, four whites — and the freedom to blend them all. Burgundy built its reputation on two grapes and never looked back. Châteauneuf-du-Pape built its reputation on the art of the assemblage. But underneath all that complexity — is there one varietal that defines the soul of the appellation?
Xavier Vignon:
Yes. The signature of the Southern-Rhône has to be – this is also the law has to be at least 50% of Grenache most of the time. So Grenache is really the big variety for the southern Rhône…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
I’m gonna jump because we’re gonna go back to your product a little bit later. But I know that in one of your wines, you have one that ‘s 100% Mourvèdre. So for my audience who doesn’t know exactly the laws and how does it works in terms of Appellation Controlée and everything. How does it work? Because the law said 50% Grenache, but you have 100% Mourvèdre.
Xavier Vignon:
Yes. In a way to become an AOP “Appellation Controlée”, you don’t respect the law so you can’t be an AOP. So all the grapes and I like that, I’m very inspired by Champagne with the freedom to make blends. I did that in many, many countries and in the Rhône with so many different varieties. I was feeling stupid to stop only with the law. So I started to make a specific blend according to the wine industry and wine laws but not to be AOP. So for example, in this Mourvèdre, it’s 100% Mourvèdre, but some Châteauneuf [inaudible], some Gigondas – I will not taking care about the Appellation, just the quality of the wine and the variety.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
You’ve spent years consulting for other estates — working within their vision, their rules, their terroir. When you finally made wine under your own name, did you have a clear idea of what you wanted it to be? Or did you let the Rhône decide?
Xavier Vignon:
For my wine? It’s a mix because of course, I like the terroir, but I like also the people. And the concept is really to respect as much as you can, what the grapes gives you the good blending session starts in the vineyard. And then the concept for me is how was it in the vineyard? What can we do? How to respect the grapes are they are… And the blending is OK: now we have done the best job as we can into the vineyard, but now blending session arrive and then you have to define your style. What do you like? And for me, many people ask me: what’s a good wine for you? After many years? Many different countries? So what’s a good wine for me? And to summarize that, I’ll say a good wine for me is a wine making me thirsty. So it’s so easy. If you have something, it has to, to tell you: take some more. it is just to have this type of pleasure of balance at the end. And for me, the Rhône one is the best place. It’s why I was really believing in that. The Rhône has this ability to make everybody happy, because if you like saltiness, if you like acidity, you can find all of that in the same bottle because the complexity of many terroirs that’s really the best recipe. If there is one recipe, the Rhône gives you a lot of complexity.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Now, the Grenache is amazing… – well, I may be biased because I love Grenache, but you can find Grenache in the south, in the Languedoc. You can find, of course, Garnacha in Spain. What’s the specificity of the Grenache of your terroir, your area?
Xavier Vignon:
Our terroir is very affected by two things: the sun like in Spain, everything. But we have a specific weather with the Mistral. So the signature of the Rhône it’s a mix between Mistral, sun and Grenache. I mean, what’s the effect of the wind when the Grenache is become ripe just before harvest? You have this effect like a hair dryer. The mistral can be hot. I speak about the Mistral during the summertime and then some years you don’t have that for me, it’s not the signature of the Rhône. It’s why some years I’m not making any wine because I don’t find what I like into the Rhône. I will say this quantity of mineral salt, minerality, but saltiness making me thirsty again. And the Grenache is the king for that; he’s really the king. If you look at the Rhône compared to the other appellation or other region, the Rhône has got much more minerals than the others because of this weather, hot and windy. This effect, because the wind makes evaporation, the old grapes, the old vines take water, water, going to the berries, evaporation, but the minerals they stay into the berries. So when this system is on, you have the real print of the Rhône. No, we have an average of 100 days a year of Mistral, but sometimes it’s not going at a good time. We need it like a dryer to make – you know that I’m very close to no pesticide, no herbicides – Mistral is our best friend. And some years when you don’t have that, then you can’t manage the style I like.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Well, you set up the next question very well. You’re talking about no pesticide. The importance of sustainability is very important. Now, it’s important for to take care of the terroir, take care of the soil and take care of your vines. Does it make better wine at the end of the day?
Xavier Vignon:
Yes […] but it’s not so easy. I think what I have seen, let’s go to 27 years in the Rhône, the challenge when I was a young winemaker – only 20; it’s yesterday morning, 27 years ago. The challenge to be a good winemaker, a good producer was to have wine with more sugar, less acidity. Now we are on totally opposite way. And when you speak about sustainability, of course, pesticide is not good; herbicide is not good, but this is not the worst. The worst is the missing water. So we have to respect more and more the water. We are not in the same world. It is going so fast. My experience of consulting everywhere into the world, the movie is so heavy and we’re going so fast that we should be much more concerned about the soil stability, which is not only to be organic, is also to respect the water. We have many dryness everywhere and I love wine. I love wine as you as you know, I like, but how to be happy if you have to use irrigation, for example, one ton of water to make one bottle of wine, there is many area started to do that. So I don’t want to go that way. My experience because I have made mistake. You plant vineyards, you don’t care about the water. And then you say years after years that you make the drinking water, you use too much drinking water. And, and that’s why the role I still have a future. If you look at the south part of Spain, it start to be very difficult. And 25 years ago we had exactly the same weather and all the data as I have with the weather change – There is a good not change but good way for us to be like that in 25 years. So to keep going with the same method that 25 years ago, it’s stupid. The challenge before was to make your best to make the wine aging faster. Now, not only in the Rhône, the challenge of a good winemaker is to protect the wine as it is and to keep it without sulfite without everything. The analysis, we pick the grapes in more than 20 years, we pick the grapes now, on average everywhere, three weeks to one month before. And in the same time, we have two percent of alcohol more. That’s the average. So we are not picking at the same date; we are not picking with the same analysis. So this is another word…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
I was talking with winemakers in Loire this summer and we had the same discussion and I want to ask you: the challenge more about because you’re very passionate about the water and the use of drinking water and no irrigation. Is this a bigger, this a bigger challenge for winemaker or the weather pattern that it’s unpredictable, that it’s a bigger challenge for you guys and especially for your area and your terroir…
Xavier Vignon:
Our terroir is already Mediterranean. So we need, we still have a good future, but we need to be very careful with the style of wine we want and the quantity and the density – many things. For example, we have done our best to have more leaves to have more sugar again, more alcohol – But now we should go back, there is a good way is to go back to the past, not to the future again. I mean bushvine can be a good solution, but in the same time, it’s becoming very difficult because you can’t use mechanic. You have to do that by hand. And this is also a real problem in France like other countries now to find the way to do that manual start to be a huge, huge difficult way.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
And you were talking about having wine that aged faster or slower earlier. Here’s a question interesting. And I wanna like, you know, this probably better than anybody. Is it true that only geology allow to make “vin de garde”? So geology, we’re talking of course about soil, clay, limestone and stuff like that…
Xavier Vignon:
Yes, you need… It’s like a three dimension wine. What you need is – don’t forget wine is – let say 13% of alcohol. The most important part of the wine everywhere is the water part. So this is not a distilled water, this is a mineral water. And if you accept that two different water, they can be so different. Not because of the tannin but because of the terroir and the minerals components, you know, you should test, I don’t know the local but Volvic, Evian, Vitel. They are so different. And the print of the terroir, the expression of the terroir is really made by the water. The water is the messenger to the terroir and geology also. But also the variety because if you have the same grapes on the same terroir, this is exactly the same terroir, you can see their neighbor 1 metre far, same weather everything, but it’s not the same old stock. If it’s not the same variety, I will say the water of Grenache is totally different than water, part of Syrah, even if they are neighbour, so each expression of terroir it’s a mix between the messenger is the water and it depends on the variety, the weather. The Mistral we spoke about, if you have a one day with a hot Mistral, you will have in total about two times to three times more minerals than in a year without Mistrial. And then to go back to the aging potential. This is compared with distilled water that you put in a glass and it is becoming moister and you have many problems after a couple of days. If it’s salty water – salt was the first to explain that. And the first way, the unique way to keep edging to do the preservative, that was the salt, and then when you have a water with more minerals, you are much more protected, which is the symbol also of the Rhône we we don’t have any a lot of acidity like Burgundy, like Ontario you have. Now we are not the best with acidity because acidity is also the best to to say, oh OK, for aging – acidity against oxidation. But this is not the wrong definition. The only way to explain that we have a good potential energy is because we are very rich in minerality and some years are better than the others because believe me, I remember 2003 and 2007, same parcel, same blend, same appellation was in Châteauneuf-du-Pape… So does exactly the same blend, exactly the same origin. And the 2007 what contain six times more minerals than the 2003 because 2003, we did not have any water. So the system, you know, to bring minerals to the berries doesn’t did not work and that the tenants profile was so different. The last experience of the – you you were speaking about Burgundy, we have only one I mean for red, we have a pinot noir, for example, Pinot Noir, one variety. Then you go there, how to explain because it’s exactly the same soil. You know the Pinot Noir from the top of the parcel, you know, 10 metres higher year is so different than the others. If you use the normal view of winemakers, I mean PH, acidity you know the 20 famous parameters, all of them are the same, all of them are the same. But how to explain that they are so different, they taste so different. All the analysis normal – just say this is the same wine. But your test means that’s the opposite. The tenants are like that and the they are more sweet here. They they are so different and even a kid can tell you, oh this is two different wines. But the winemaker take his 20 analysis, they are exactly the same. The only way to explain that is to have a look like on the back label, on the water back label, you have only the mineral components. And if I started to do that the first time in 2007 and it’s like a new door open, this is the real expression of the wine, the water part. And then this is the terroir.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Europe has been debating mandatory ingredient labeling on wine for a few years now — and the industry has been divided. You already include mineral content on your labels, which puts you ahead of that conversation. Does ingredient transparency make sense to you? And more broadly — how do you think the industry needs to adapt, not just in the cellar, but in how it communicates what’s actually in the bottle?
Xavier Vignon:
It makes sense. It makes sense to to consider, to look at the old varieties, new varieties because first we have to adapt. I told you at the beginning: what we had 20 years ago are totally different than what we have now, for example, we were looking for more sugar. So in the past, some varieties, they were totally destroyed because they don’t have enough sugar, they don’t have enough – they had too much acidity. I we can speak about […]. And now because the climate is so different, they could be not an enemy like they were the people they were not stupid. I think everybody was right at a good time. But we should be more open to new varieties because of that the – the challenge to have now more acidity, maybe it is to go back to certain variety, but there is no law, you know, each case is a particular case. But for me, I have some example in Châteauneuf-du-Pape because Châteauneuf-du-Pape was elected AOP in ‘45 1945. So most of the wine now you test are made with the list of 17 varieties as we spoke before. But there is still some vineyard older – plenty a long time before 1945. But they have also different varieties still alive we use and some of them, they were condemned in 1945 because there were not enough colour, not enough sweetness. But now, so they were like the enemy of the Appelation. Now they are maybe their best friend, the best friend and, and for me, we have to open the door of new varieties or when I say new varieties or back to very old varieties. Cinsault is also a good example but Cinsault means also because the consumers, they have changed their mind. Cinsault used to be OK. Light not tanic, not acidic, not a lot of color. And it was like OK, if you are, if you buy your land of Cinsault, so you have to take them off. It’s what happened a lot in the Rhône. And now Cinsault because you consume your life, the wine lighter than before, Cinsault become the new star. But I remember some people with Carignan also – for example, we have Vacqueyras; Vacqueyras used to have Carignan, but Carignan was not ripe enough for the people. So, and I remember they, they have asked to the old producer, one was crying, it was in 25 years ago and they decided to, ok all the producers, you have to take off all your Carignan. And I was in a meeting two years ago because all of them, they have to respect the rule because if they don’t do, the Vacqueyras was becoming Vin de France. You know, the impact financial impact was horrible. And two years ago, I was at the same meeting with new people and said, I have an idea. It will be great if we can plant Carignan. And I was like, I was thinking about the people crying about it and, and, this is not only in France but French are very easy for that, but the laws are moving, the climate is changing faster than the law. We have to consider the new varieties. And I think also we have, don’t forget because new varieties are ok for many things it can help for – I was in Greece not a long time ago, Assyrtiko. Some people think about new varieties coming from south part to keep acidity and it could work. The only problem is that’s ok. You can change the variety but don’t forget, it does not matter which variety it is, but we need water. So when you have a dryness problem, there is no solution with new varieties because if you do with whatever the, the, the variety you play with um the wine at the end, we will add 85% of water. And then I’m really against the new system irrigation we have to control because – Ontario is a good example. When I started to work, the northern limit of the northern hemisphere was Champagne. It is not anymore. You have sparkling UK, you have a very pretty good wine. Now, Pinot Noir Chardonnay in Ontario, I was since a couple of years, I can see that it’s on the good move. So maybe we have to accept that the new worldwide will be up to the north in the north hemisphere and up to the south in the south hemisphere.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
So I hear some of my members of my audience saying is biodiversity. So those indigenous varietal that, you know, the authority wants to get rid of, is this the savior? Maybe of all the best weapons against climate change?
Xavier Vignon:
A part of it maybe not 100% because there are so many factors. But I’m really convinced that I have some example in Turkey, they used to hav grapes for many, many years, a long time before France, for example. And when you find they all grapes, they were not very on the commercial way before, but they don’t care because they were doing distillation. And now you can access to this type of all. I have seen some vines more than 150 years old with specific variety does not exist anymore. But when you have the chance to go back and then for distillation, there was no problem. So they are still alive because they did not decide to take them off because they were not making that to make wine. But now when you have the chance to make wine with this type of variety, you discover another world and they are 150 years old. So there – I remember um I discovered also in a in a close to south part of China. So you have something totally different, totally new. We had some experience also in Turkey. So there is still some many new places and the same time old places, the wine is really a part of the humanity for me.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
The market is sending signals — lower alcohol, lighter styles, a younger generation drinking differently than their parents did. You work across enough regions and enough countries to have a real read on this. What does the consumer actually want right now — and do you believe it?
Xavier Vignon:
Yeah. That’s true. People are more concerned about the alcohol level and which is a nightmare for us in the Rhône Valley because of course, alcohol is a part of the blend. I never seen a good Grenache at 12.5% of alcohol. No, because we need, we have a specific wine. When you make a blend, it has to be balanced. So alcohol is the antagonist of the dryness from tannis when you make a blend, especially when you have some specific tannin are like the seeds of Grenache, like the the skin some years like a bit Pinot Noir, but much more, much, much more with the Grenache. So these typical tanners, they need alcohol, they need saltiness to find an antagonist to the dryness. And then if you go back because we have the technology to take off the alcohol. But I really prefer because at the end between a 13% of alcohol or 14.5 this 1.5% I prefer to drink less but to still have still have something in balance and and but you’re right. The problem is for me, there is a limit if you want to keep the balance. Alcohol, maybe you have tested some no alcohol wine for me. It’s not the wine I understand the idea the concept to have less alcohol. We have done many tries with 7% of alcohol to some, but we are not in the same segment for me wine and also for the conservation for the style. And as I told you a good one for me has to make me feel thirsty. And then, and then if you switch off this segment doesn’t mean doesn’t make me happy…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines – MID-POINT:
Good wine has to make me thirsty. Well said, Xavier. Well said. And what Xavier just described about alcohol in the Rhône is worth sitting with for a moment. Alcohol isn’t an afterthought there — it’s structural. It’s part of the blend the same way tannin is, the same way acidity is. The terroir, the climate, the geology, the varietals — Grenache: the grapes of the Southern Rhône and the Côtes Catalanes — they require a certain level of alcohol to come alive. That’s not a defense of high alcohol wine. It’s simply the truth of what these places grow and why. It simply doesn’t work any other way. If this conversation is landing for you — and I have a feeling it is — please subscribe on Spotify or Apple Podcasts right now. It costs nothing, it takes five seconds, and it’s the only way to make sure you never miss what’s coming next. Back to Xavier. He’s just described a winemaker who refuses to stay still — consulting across continents, adapting to climates, reading terroir like a language. So I asked him: in this era of constant change, what matters more? Consistency, year over year? Or innovation? And what happens when Mother Nature makes that choice for you? Here’s Xavier.
Xavier Vignon:
I think it’s a balance because you need them. If you keep only the tradition way, you don’t, you don’t go so fast and you too, you’re going too slow. So you need innovation, for example, in the last 10 years, it’s not a revolution but um again, the wine, the recipe we used to use. So ok, the consistency is good. I have also my brand, so this is Xavier brand. So the style has to be defined. But for innovation, you have to accept that um the grapes are changing. So you have to accept that the wine at the end will change also. And then you have something else to show. And the most important today is in this type of even innovation. Each time when you make a blend, it’s really something I’m concerned about when you make a blend, you have to think, not only at the test you have on the instanty, it’s more is that it could be a wine for future. Is that a wine? I’m very proud to say I did not use that water. No irrigation. I was at a good place. Can I make it again in 10 years? Can I make it often? So this is the pressure we should have all the winemakers when we do something. It has to be a long term reflection. And I think the tradition is long term behind, but it’s a short term most of the time, it’s a long term behind us. Tradition. Let’s go to do that. And I feel so stupid sometimes because we don’t want to change and then we can see the wall and instead to walk slowly, we will run to the, to the wall and, then I’m, I’m really sick about that. I think it’s like we, every year we have a new recalls, the datas are like that alcohol level. We spoke about the alcohol. So we make recalls every year, every year and then we say, ok, but I am also a scientific guy and the exponent show, it’s easy to make the draw and then there is no possible big change in a few next year. So we are going to have records and records we have every year is a record. Now, this year in Rhône and not in the one is a new record of hot temperature in October. So we had 44 degrees after the 15th of August always records because of alcohol because of that. And what’s happened in some countries when they have this record and they start and they keep going with the wine, then we have the solution to dissolve the wine. I’ve seen that in many countries, the one becomes too salty. So we have to use technology to take off the alcohol. If you OK, we have the technology, we can do acidification with more brand. So we don’t have any acid. So we have the technology like coming from the medical way. The problem is when we use this technology, we use a lot of water to make it. It’s like the to dissolve the the water to make it drinkable. How many water you use – a lot? If you want to take off the alcohol, how many to take off 1% of alcohol in one bottle, you will use 2 bottle of drinking water and sustainable. No, it’s not sustainable. And then maybe and it’s difficult – I understand especially the tradition because for many generations, I can believe the people, they have five generations of winemaker or producer at that place. But if that place becoming a nightmare, like we can see sometimes you know, the Pyrénées-Orientales just to speak in France, they did not have any water for one year. So if they had that for years succeeded, it’s a semi desert. Is it still sustainable to keep going with the wine? And it’s difficult I understand after many to consider that one day, you have to push the button stop and to make some to move. But it’s not easy when you are a winemaker consultant to do that with some people. They are coming from this [inaudible] generations. But I think you should take on yourself that this is not the way to, to go. And I have many experiences with – you bite together because no, I don’t want to do that. I don’t want to the solution of irrigation – that, that place is not, it’s not the long term. And then I’ve got two kids and I hope they will have kids. And then if we keep going that way, we made, we make a big, big mistake and I have many examples. It’s like sometimes the yellow to [inaudible] organic using copper. I’ve seen that if everybody was using only copper and sulfur, the soil is becoming like the moon. So we have to be more intelligent to say what does some stability means? It’s not only – of course, pesticide is not to use is great herbicide, but it’s not enough. We have to consider much more and I like the consumers, everybody looking at the taking care about the water, we have to take care of all the water. And in France we start to speak about that. But I had this problem 20 – 30 years ago in Australia. So I was really touched by that and I feel bad because it’s like just now because it’s almost too late that we start to speak about that seriously. Unfortunately, it’s like a drug but it is very serious. I remember, you know, the French sometimes are very French. And I remember when I was a consultant going to Australia and they, oh, you, you should not expect our knowledge in another country. You teach them too much. There was many producers like that and I told them, no, no, I’m not going to teach them. I’m going to learn because they have physical methods. They are very concerned about that. And in the same time, some of them, they are extreme people, very traditional. No, they should not make wine because they use irrigation. They use acidification – they should not be able to make wine. And it was 25 years ago and I had a meeting not a long time ago on conference on global warming effect in the wine. And I’ve seen the same people and I was telling, remember I put a video, remember when you told me that they are not supposed to go to make wine because they have this type of PH they have to use the irrigation. Look at our analysis now and true analysis. So if you are honest with yourself, can you tell the same that you told me for yourself 25 years after? And that is oh no, no, but we don’t have choice but we have choice. We have choice, we have choice to, to move. We have to accept – It’s not nothing happening in two days but in 25 years, we have to consider that what we have to think about the next 25 years.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
So when you fell in love with the Dentelles up until now, does the, the expression is, does the gold line change that your objective and your blueprint of wine have changed? Or are you basically the same objective, the same target or it has changed because of the terroir have change, the climate have changed.
Xavier Vignon:
And you learn to be to become and we try to be modest because you have to change for many reasons. The best aera of yesterday are not the best aera now. So they move so they are different. The consumers they have changed also, I remember the gold medals was the one very tannin when you used to say, ok, I can put that in my cellar for 10 years – It was also 25 years, 30 years ago. We did the vintage and the wine before to be bottled was in the cellar was keeping in the cellar for 3 – 4 years. Now, most of the time after harvest the next spring, we do the bottling most of the time. So not only because of the global warming, but the wine, the test everything has changed. So how to say that you keep going on the same way because you’re not in the same world, you’re not smelling the same, you know, everything is on the move. The only thing I will say it was the good place to be is because I was right. The future is going up to the altitude. So it’s difficult to go to the north for me, but to go to the altitude and we still have the chance to plant with north exposed, we have good white now; in the past, it was only a south exposed everywhere to be able to make wine. So we have to explore also the other exposure – north exposed can be very nice. Sometimes we have that in the Dentelles and the best at the moment is to go – the limit was 100 metres, everything over 100 metres. The limit was Châteauneuf-du-Pape: 130 metres and on the top of Châteauneuf was not the best place to be, which is now the best place to be… and then over now I will say that in the Valley – in the Rhône Valley, when you are in very close to the valley is not a good place to be. I can say Plan-de-Dieu that is – because we miss water. We have another climate but the best around going and moving to the altitude. And for example, I love the Beaumes-de-Venise because this is the highest point for vineyard in the south one. You can go up to 800 m and it used to be a nightmare to be over 200 m and now it’s the best place to be – only in 25 years.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Wow. And you mentioned earlier that the Pyrénées-Orientales had like a big drought like they didn’t have any rain. Now, in terms of altitude, where are they exactly, compared to you?
Xavier Vignon:
They have also the chance to have altitude. So they, they were, they were safe about that in the P.O. but you close to the sea. So they don’t go so up but they still have the mountain and they are the proximity with the sea, but even with that, so the humidity is not enough. So it’s, I have many friends there. I was doing the blend with this type of year. It’s a nightmare because we need water again when you have too much tunnels. When you have too much press the vineyard gives you what it was suffering. So you have problem to manage. You have to consider that the wine could not stay like it is, you have to do something and then maybe it can be technology and after many, many years, this is the recipe for me. If the wine has to be touched for fighting for something, even in history, he has an accident, I don’t want to take it because this accident will come one day. It’s like when I was young, I had a problem of my knees and then, ok, but you arrive to 55 like me now and then. Oh, yeah. Now, and the wine is exactly like that when you have a problem to manage, then one day the this problem will, will take…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
It’s gonna kick it, it’s gonna bite you in the butt. [Yeah, exactly.] Have you seen drastic change in terms of taste preference? So we talk about level of alcohol; we talk about the tan and does the new consumer and the reason why I’m asking this because there’s many reports that came out that says that the millennials are like not as big wine fans than the previous generation and sales are going down because of the new generation. So do you see a trend like that? That it’s like, worry you and your colleagues and friends ?
Xavier Vignon:
A lot because this change of course, when we say the consumers change their mind about the wine, it’s also like an education. I love Bordeaux, but Bordeaux is a good example. They were keeping going of. I don’t want to say anything bad about Bordeaux. But there are, there are, there is a big crisis there. They was keep going with some specific tannin. They was really keeping the tradition wood barrels – woody character and, and the young generation especially maybe because we had the chance with the South hemisphere to make new consumers. I could not believe today the old world without the south hemisphere because I’m doing some considering many places. But for example, UK, Northern Europe, this is the countries open their mind to the wine. They used to drink no wine. And if you look at that’s why I’m still very optimist. All the new countries going to the wine, they are more open to not to the tradition to the modernity to test something new. The South hemisphere was making a lot of a clean, you know, it’s not and also with the marketing but clean wine, you know, Sauvignon clean. So the people, they were, it was more easier to start to drink wine with this type of wine than with a Bordeaux, you should say, OK, it’s very, you know, the first time – I’m doing some um with young students and learning some exercise with very young people. I mean, I teach them how to spit and then how to test a bit. So of course, I don’t give alcohol to the kids but I really like the this, this effect to the kids because they, they are very sensitive and then how to go to the tannin, for example, which is could be aggressive. So you need to have a culture of that. So to start the wine sparkling is easy, then you start with wine and then rosé and wine is coming down because you have to adapt. It’s an education and with the new generation, they are more open because if you take off the wine, there are different beers, they are different drinks. So their palate, they need the modernity. They don’t need to have a freestyle, something to drink. It’s like music, it’s not, I listen to classic music, they need techno, they need jazz, they so they are very open because with the social media, you open to many, many things and it’s much more easier when you start to drink wine now. maybe not in France. But if you are in some countries like, like here, you can access to wine from everywhere into the world. And then I’ve seen a big difference between the country open to different countries like here, like in Sweden, I was speaking about – when you are in France, your education become a problem because you don’t access easily to if you want still now to buy Australian wine in France or Ontario Wine, Ontario wine in France, it’s not easy. So, and then, in the same time, we say, but they are not drinking French wine anymore – because we did not give them access to other countries. And I really thought that way to give the opportunity to test different wines and all the winemakers believe to drink the same wine every day. That was the problem with some old people. They drink their wine only and then they are not open to anything else.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
In a world where a wine lover can choose between Australian Shiraz, New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc, California Cabernet, and the entire canon of French wine — all on the same shelf — how does a producer like you cut through? And more specifically, how do you reach the next generation of drinkers, the ones who will define what wine means for the next fifteen years?
Xavier Vignon:
Yeah, it’s a mix between, for me like sustainability, you have to not only tell what you’re doing but also doing what you are telling – to be more engaged because – the, the one as I’m, I’m going back to the Rhône because I have to take my space with the and for me, the Rhône has this power of making not only making everybody happy, but the style of wine can give a good response for the people looking for something fruity, giving a good response for people looking. I will be, I will say that for me, the Rhône is very cosmopolite test and it can be served cold, it can be served, you know, it can be for all seasons. If you like salty, you like the Rhône. If you like acidity, you can, you can access also to good pairing and in terms of pairing because of this richness in salinity and minerality, I think the Rhône can go sometimes with fish, can go with – we had many examples with that because the one we don’t speak about that in Europe. But when you work with some Asian specialists, then they’re speaking about I and if you are close to Umami, Rhône is very rich in umami too. So I was very surprised not a long time ago on a sushi, a very big chef in Japan. And then I’ve seen my Gigondas on that with fish and I said, wow, would be difficult for me. But my wine was totally different, but the pairing was great. So it’s also a new door open when you mix that so it, but to do that, you have to travel, you can’t stay at the same place. I could not believe my life staying only in the Rhône and in my winery just, that’s the life of concerting that you are still out of ideas. You like to meet people.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
So it’s the worst kept secret that for me, the story is everything, the story of the winemakers, the story of the winery is everything. It’s more important than anything else. But at the same time, I’m not on the other end of the table where I need to move bottles from my cellar to the shelf to the consumer table. Story is one thing, but of course, when you get a good score from a wine magazine, it’s also important because still today consumers are gonna buy based on scores. What’s your take on that? What’s more important? The story or the score?
Xavier Vignon:
No, the scores. I’m very, of course, it was good for me – I remember I had good scores with Parker and everything and I don’t, I don’t say something bad about that just yet. This is not the most important. The most important is really the fact to be proud of what you’re doing. So there is a problem if you want to do that, only with money -for money, you will make many mistakes. So you have to take this distance about making a wine is not a recipe. It’s you play with nature and she is the queen and then sometimes you accept that what you are doing is not good. But when it is not good, are you happy to give that into the, to put that into the bottle and to give it to your friends? No. So we have to accept also to, this is typical from the wine you have to accept not to do sometimes just to respect the consistency, maybe just to respect that. So the challenge is to be honest and modest with yourself. I always said you have to be different. You know, I don’t like the idea to look at the copy when you are a winemaker some people you start to work with, they say, oh, I would like to have this style or in some countries, I would like to make a Côte-Rôtie – I would like to make a wine. And I hate that because I always say no, you have to create your own, which is nice because there is no recipe with the wine. And then even if you use the same variety at the same place, the wine with two different people will become different. So the objective and it’s why I really like the wine – the wine is international expression. It’s a international language and you can speak about what you’re doing, you can listen to the people and finally, the one is maybe the most important part of the one is the dream part. And I’m not sure that the scores if somebody give the scores, they say, well, this one is included in the 100 best wines of the world, but for who, for one people, but not for all the world. And, then a good example which changes the thing is like the natural wine coming So for a winemaker, sometimes you see something we are educated to find diseases, problems. And sometimes you have to accept that people like for a winemaker could be a problem. So for people, they should like it… [yeah].
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
You’ve spent decades consulting across continents, watching the industry from the inside. You’ve seen what works, what doesn’t, and what refuses to change even when it should. Setting aside climate — because as you said, she’s the queen and nobody argues with the queen — what would you change tomorrow if you could?
Xavier Vignon:
To accept one day that you have to be in balance. I mean, the water, water again, you have to make sure that what you’re doing is respecting everything around, not only the wine but the other trees, the insects, the I’m very open to move that way and also to, to be more honest with the wine. So the style of wine will be, don’t change – we have the chance now to have a ripe. So we don’t need like in the past to add something to the wine like o like I like barrels of course, but most of the time now we have the chance to find the new grapes are riper than before they can give you a beautiful juice and the challenge maybe is to keep them as they are. And when you say that the acidity is going down, the alcohol is going up. So in a way, people that like me, we don’t want to use sulfite more than before, we want to use less sulfite. So the challenge is to find and we have some ideas on that the way to be more conservative with more – with less conservative products. And you have, we have to change the process. One example for me is if you want to respect the wine, there is some cuvée, we are tested together – the concept to accept that. When you put this wine in a concrete tank, it changes the taste; when you put this wine in a barrel, it changes the taste; when you put that in an amphora, it changes the taste. If you put that in a stainless steel tank, it changes a lot of the taste and we discovered that the best for that was the glass. So maybe to respect that the wine as it is, let’s go because we have a good experience with button. So the glass can be the best contenant for the wine. This is something also we don’t want to create to add something we just want to respect. And the glass is very sustainable because you can have for eternity. You have a tank easy to clean and doesn’t change the taste. This is the only thing doesn’t change the taste we have over processed. We spoke about the immersion process – I was – this is innovation but innovation not with using electricity just using what we have already. When you submerge the wine to the wine, it doesn’t cost you more money. It just you, you protect it like a baby in the wound. And this type of aging – we start now but I’m sure that in 20 years many instead to use, we have a cellar just behind me, using electricity using and to keep the wine at 18 degrees, maybe 14. And the future will be more to be less sensitive to the temperature. But for example, to keep the bottle in the liquid or a specific liquid like water and then you don’t have to be scared about the oxidation and then you don’t have to be scared if the temperature is going up to 22. So you don’t use electricity and you just use a liquid for a long, long term. It’s like we have to switch, ok now, but tomorrow and for my next generation and it’s like – it looks like to me that they used to do that in the past, even if there were less concerned, but now it’s just looking – like politics, you know, my mandatory is just seven years. Ok? And no, please. I am still optimist, but…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Let’s talk about the wines. And let’s start with the one that genuinely surprised me — Arcane Le Diable. 100% Mourvèdre. A single vintage, a single blend, never to be repeated. Xavier — tell us about Le Diable. How does a wine like this come to exist?
Xavier Vignon:
The wine – It’s why it’s another range. I could not sign that because it’s not a Xavier, it’s a Arcanes; It’s a new concept of it’s not a concept. It’s just the ability to like a photography. You have one instant; it’s something special happened and then you put that into the bottom and you don’t care about to reply. All the Arcanes are just one blend, one bottling and that’s it. So the label will be put only on one blend, never repeat again. Because as I told you, normally the Côtes-du-Rhône has to be – now it’s the law has to be, it’s a new law has to be a mix of at least 50% of Grenache, but in 2015, I discover the common point was the Mourvèdre facing to the sunrise and in altitude and everything was picked in ‘15. But this moment it’s why the nickname of Mourvèdre was many times the devil because he was never arrived. But that time, so we did not pick because if we picked the wine will be very ugly and we wait, we wait. And after one month, something happened, we never seen before. Normally the acidity is going down, the sugar is going up. So the winemaker looking was, wow, I’ve never seen that happen before. Some old producer – 85 I remember one close to 90 years old said, wow, I never seen that. And the test was so different. Maybe it was the open mind to the new global warming. And we discover 100% Mourvèdre as we never seen before. And the challenge was to make a specific cuvée and the idea was ok to mix that, to give something else to the other blend, but it did not work. That wine was only great when he was alone. So he did not accept any other wine and he no wine could accept a bit of it. And I never seen that before too. Ok. I said, let’s go. There is a message with Mourvèdre in the Rhône because the nickname of the devil maybe is the king now because his keeps acidity, it doesn’t make so much alcohol is really fashion now and not only for the taste because the analysis are correct. It used to be a nightmare to be, to work with Mourvèdre now it’s a paradise. So I decided to make this one cuvée switching the ok, this is Mourvèdre it could not be Côtes-du-Rhône, it’s coming from the Rhône Valley but it’s a Vin de France because of 100% Mourvèdre.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Mourvèdre is well known in the Rhône, and across the Languedoc-Roussillon where it anchors the classic GSM blend alongside Grenache and Syrah. But one hundred percent Mourvèdre — no blend, no compromise — that’s something else entirely. Xavier, has this ever been done before in the Rhône?
Xavier Vignon:
I think in the Rhône, yeah, there’s a good chance that that was not made before. No, but it’s also when I told you how to be different – when you make blends, when you are free, like me consulting, you don’t have to, to make, but sometimes you, this freedom gives you the power to do something that the that did not do already. And I really, I like it – It’s the, it’s like I told you I was very inspired, especially by the Champagne, the blending in Champagne, you know, we can say non-vintage, this is not a problem. So I was the first to make multi-vintages in the Rhône even in Châteauneuf-du-Pape with non-vintage, but I don’t like to say non-vintage for me, it was for example, to give more complexity using multi-vintages. But the culture to be different is also coming from a generation – It’s a challenge we – you have to do. If you have to do something, it could not be a copy, it has to be different than the others. And with modesty, of course, I don’t say that this is better than the others. I just say okay, this is something different.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
The next one we have, the Côte-du-Rhône 2020. So this one here, right… This one is a GSM. So 85% Grenache, 10% Syrah 5% Mourvèdre. Tell us about the wine please.
Xavier Vignon:
Yeah, for me, the Côte-du-Rhône is really the my maybe my favorite because I like how to make it. You know, the Côte-du-Rhône is the biggest area I can play with because I’m based in the Southern Rhône. So it gave me a view on for example, inside there is 120 different producers. So it means that you have more than 700 parcels. It’s really inspired again from the freedom you have to take or not to take in Champagne a long time ago. And what I like in that is a concentrated, I will say you have almost all the terroi from the Côte-du-Rhône and the style has to be what I like from the Rhône, giving you fruit, flowers, spices. And it’s difficult to have the consistency because this is a sea natural wine. So when I make it, I want the people to recognize the style and but not the Xavier style, maybe a bit, but it’s more the Rhône style and old Grenache – What does it mean old Grenache? Why I work only with old Grenache? Sometimes you have good wines with young Grenache, but then they don’t have the ability for aging long time. So what I like with this type of wine, it’s a 2020 Grenache varietal means and good Mistrial this year. So a lot of saltiness, a lot of minerality and fresh food. It it looks like sometimes some Pinot Noir. We, we have also this pleasure in the run some years to have the the red berries, note of Pinot Noir and spices. So that’s something I really like in this type of wine. And old vines means at least 80 years old, which is a gift because the Rhône I love it because the old Grenache is much more better than the young. So we have to protect that. It means the production level of that when you take a lot of different producer, you don’t have to take a lot of them. It’s just like in perfume and you, you put something never a lot. You know, if you do the calculation one producer represent less than 1%. So it’s really small volume making a nice cuvée and it’s like a big team and of course, I like rugby, but there is more than 15 players on that.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
I can appreciate rugby, but I don’t know enough to continue the conversation here; the aging potential on this wine — tell us about that please.
Xavier Vignon:
When you have the round tea to have this level of mineral salts, then it’s like the difference between distilled water and salty water. When you have enough salt, then that’s the best frame for aging. So I will say that for the Rhône, for me, the signature of the Rhône, the production level is very low. It’s one vine makes one bottle. We have 4000 vines per hectare anyway, the density, but don’t go too far. So to respect that you have to work with old vines. And when you have for me, it’s the best balance about one vine makes one bottle, you don’t need too much water, you don’t need you, you really balance for the future. And I like the style because at that level, it’s not too tanic, it’s very rich in minerals. So I will say the best time is between 3 to 6 years or for all the people, for the people, they like it young. That’s also what I like in the Rhône. You can drink it when he he’s two years old. That’s the Rhône effect. And if you like edging a bit more, it’s easy to say that 12 years, 10 years will be still good spicy. It depends the what fruit becoming more flowers and spices. But the big mix for me when I make the blend, I like to have yeah fruit, red fruit, black fruit, spices, which is the Rhône and to have flowers in the same time, it has to be between, yeah, 2 to 6 years. You are sure not to make a big mistake.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Ok, finally, the last wine — and arguably the most fascinating of all. Cuvée Anonyme, Châteauneuf-du-Pape 2019. 60% Grenache, 15% Mourvèdre, 10% Syrah — and then, other varietals. That’s where the story begins. Xavier — tell us about the Anonyme. What’s behind the name, and what’s behind the blend?
Xavier Vignon:
This is – the name of Anonyme came for many reasons because when I started to make this cuvée was in 2005, because 2005, I can, I was of course in Châteauneuf and then I have seen some big producers with still some all we call it Collection vineyard. So if you go to Châteauneuf , now you will see that there is still about 1% of the vineyard, maybe less now of Collection vineyard. In the same parcel, you have all all all vines, most of them planting just after Phylloxera. It means that they have now 125 years, 130 years. And what’s happened in Châteauneuf when the AOP was created was in 1945 they say, ok to have the consistency, we make a list of the famous 17 varieties. So we have 13 reds and 4 whites and everything you’re going to plant until now has to be on this list if you want to take the AOP Châteauneuf-du-Pape. But before that, they have many other varieties and they did not say the one before 1945 won’t be Châteauneuf anymore. So they changed progressively, they changed to make all the vineyard with that, we still have the chance to have this old vineyard and the history is why it’s Anonyme because if you ask me the percentage of which variety we have done a genetic research in one parcel, we have more than 70 different varieties. It’s very incredible and then what they did which is maybe a future to use when one wine. Now if one vine is dead because in the old parcel, you have some, you have about 2 to 3% every year becoming dead for disease for everything. So if you don’t do anything for 20 years, you know, we won’t have a lot. But this one, they were alive much more longer because they were less sensitive. What they did – for example, you have a different 11 in the middle of two neighbors dead instead to plant a new one from the list. They used to at the pruning time to put one benches into the soil and to cross with the neighbors. So it’s becoming hybrid. We call it “marcottage”. And then the good idea what I like to do that now is because when you plant a new vine in the middle of all vines, you need to go to give a lot of water and it’s a very especially now difficult to stay alive to, to keep alive a vineyard when you, you start like that and because of the dryness and then you have to take the tractor to give water to that and, and this way to take bunches and to put that, it makes fruits very faster and it’s very, the water is given by the father and the mother and it’s really something we should consider. Like in the past, I told you at the beginning, many new fashion should be regarded in what they did in the past.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Xavier my friend, two final questions before we let you go — and I want your honest answer on this one, because you’ve been everywhere, you’ve consulted on almost every continent, and you have no reason to be diplomatic. In your opinion — what is the most underrated wine region in the world right now? The one that deserves far more attention than it’s getting…
Xavier Vignon:
With sparkling, I was very impressed by the UK. You mean the good quality coming I was very impressed by when you like sparkling like me Champagne I mean, I had some cuvée I was very impressed with the expression. I can’t find what we could not find anymore in the Champagne. A nice acidity and maybe the last big big emotion was with German Reisling. I was just you know the type of one you start to cry, you cry and because it’s really a big emotion why it is. It is. And, and yeah, telling me that maybe the future is more in the north.
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines:
Xavier — last question. Something tells me your proudest achievement hasn’t happened yet. So let me ask it differently: what’s still on the to-do list?
Xavier Vignon:
Maybe to create a vineyard in a place there was no vineyard. That’s really something I have two projects. To be honest, one with a winery without plastic, only gravity, not using electricity – winery like in the past with a modern touch. I work on it and the real challenge will be to find a new place when there is no vineyard at all, but in balance for the next century and I have some ideas with altitude, everything but it won’t be in France. I think it would be nice for me to go maybe close to Canada. We never know if somebody is looking for a French guy…
Pierre Ferland – Read Between the Wines – CLOSING:
A good wine has to make me thirsty. He said that once, almost in passing — and it has stayed with me. Because in four words, Xavier Vignon just dismantled everything the wine world thinks it’s doing. Not the scores. Not the tasting notes. Not the appellation rules or the oak regime or the extraction philosophy. Just this: does it make you want more? That is the real lesson of Xavier Vignon. Not the 70 varieties in a single parcel. Not the Mourvèdre nobody had done before. Not the Guide Hachette nightmare or the accidental négociant or the Mistral he waits for like a conversation partner. The honesty. The restlessness. And the quiet conviction that wine, at its best, is simply the most expressive language on earth. A sincere thank you to Xavier Vignon for his generosity, his time, and for the kind of thinking about wine and terroir and water and the future that you simply don’t hear anywhere else. And a very special thank you to the entire team at Noble Estates for making this conversation possible — and for bringing Xavier’s wines to Canada. We are proud to be part of telling this story. If you are a wine producer anywhere in the world and you believe that what you do deserves to be heard — we would love to hear from you. Head over to readbetweenthewines.com and get in touch. Let’s tell your story next. And if you haven’t already, follow us on Instagram and subscribe on your favourite streaming platform — including Spotify. It makes a real difference. That’s a wrap for Episode 47 of Read Between the Wines — Xavier Vignon — what a conversation. I’m Pierre Ferland. Until next time — Cheers. Santé.
Join the conversation